01
Plans in PlanTools
The benchmarking database is built from the plans held in PlanTools, not from a survey and not from Form 5500 filings.
Benchmarking
PlanTools sets what a plan pays beside plans of the same size in PlanTools, measured by participants and by assets, so the committee compares like with like and records a conclusion.
01
The benchmarking database is built from the plans held in PlanTools, not from a survey and not from Form 5500 filings.
02
Every plan is reviewed and checked before it joins a peer group.
03
Each plan sits in one of 13 asset ranges and one of 12 participant ranges, so it is compared apples to apples.
Fee benchmarking
The plan’s total cost, and each part of it, against its peer universe.
The Fee Benchmarking page in the Monitoring Report sets the plan’s investment, recordkeeping, and administration costs beside the fee low, the fee average, and the fee high of the plans it is compared with, in dollars or as a percent of plan assets.
Cost per participant sits on the same page, so a flat-fee arrangement and an asset-based one can be read side by side.
When a fee is missing for the plan, its cell shows a dash, and the peer benchmarks for that fee stay in the table. The sample plan has no TPA / Administration fee on file, so the fee low, average, and high are still there to compare against.
Fee benchmarking
Monitoring Report
Show fees in
Your plan
Fee low
Fee average
Fee high
Your plan
Fee low
Fee average
Fee high
Total cost in the peer universe
$1,594 below the fee average in total, and $122 less per participant.
Peer group ranges
Each fee is benchmarked against plans with the same number of participants, and separately against plans with the same assets, because more recordkeepers now charge a flat fee rather than a share of assets.
The total, and every service provider’s share of it.
Total plan fees, recordkeeping and administration, investment management, custody, advisory, and 3(16) fees each show the size of their peer universe, the cost per head, the dollars, and the percent of plan assets.
A bar places the fee between the 10th and 90th percentile of its peers. Switch between the asset range and the participant range to see both comparisons.
Peer group ranges
Benchmarking
Total plan fees
0.79%
Between the 50th and 75th percentiles
Recordkeeping / Admin
0.30%
Between the 50th and 75th percentiles
Investment management
0.25%
Between the 50th and 75th percentiles
Custodian fee
0.04%
Between the 25th and 50th percentiles
Advisory fee
0.20%
Between the 10th and 25th percentiles
3(16) fee
0.33%
No peer range for this fee
Total plan fees
0.79%
Between the 50th and 75th percentiles
Recordkeeping / Admin
0.30%
Between the 50th and 75th percentiles
Investment management
0.25%
Between the 50th and 75th percentiles
Custodian fee
0.04%
Between the 25th and 50th percentiles
Advisory fee
0.20%
Between the 10th and 25th percentiles
3(16) fee
0.33%
No peer range for this fee
01
The data behind each range comes from the professionals who consult with those plans. The DOL does not require choosing service providers on the lowest fees or the average fees.
02
The tails are left out by focusing on the 10th to 90th percentile. In our experience, fees between the 25th and 75th percentile are in a relatively safe zone, and plans that want superior services and experienced experts will likely pay more.
03
A reasonable total does not make every component reasonable; each one has to be. The final authority on reasonableness is the responsible plan fiduciary, and the decision rests on the services rendered for the fees paid.
The database
The PlanTools benchmarking database is populated from the plans in PlanTools: plans that arrive through recordkeeping data feeds, and plans advisors import or create.
Plans arrive through recordkeeping data feeds into PlanTools.
Advisors import plans by API or SFTP, or through an ingestion method PlanTools provides to enterprise clients.
Advisors create plans directly in the platform.
What goes in
Every plan’s data is reviewed and quality-checked, then placed in a participant range and an asset range, so a plan is only ever compared with plans of its size.
What stays out
Surveys and Form 5500 filings are inaccurate and inconsistent. They are unreliable sources, and benchmarks built on them have been thrown out when fee cases go to trial.
Ranges
Every plan is placed in one of each and benchmarked against the plans in the same range. Then tighten the range with a scale you set.
| Range | Plan assets |
|---|---|
| 01 | Under $100,000 |
| 02 | $100,000 – $499,999 |
| 03 | $500,000 – $999,999 |
| 04 | $1,000,000 – $2,499,999 |
| 05 | $2,500,000 – $4,999,999 |
| 06 | $5,000,000 – $9,999,999 |
| 07 | $10,000,000 – $14,999,999 |
| 08 | $15,000,000 – $24,999,999 |
| 09 | $25,000,000 – $49,999,999 |
| 10 | $50,000,000 – $99,999,999 |
| 11 | $100,000,000 – $249,999,999 |
| 12 | $250,000,000 – $499,999,999 |
| 13 | $500,000,000 or more |
| Range | Participants |
|---|---|
| 01 | 1 |
| 02 | 2 – 10 |
| 03 | 11 – 25 |
| 04 | 26 – 50 |
| 05 | 51 – 100 |
| 06 | 101 – 249 |
| 07 | 250 – 499 |
| 08 | 500 – 999 |
| 09 | 1,000 – 2,499 |
| 10 | 2,500 – 4,999 |
| 11 | 5,000 – 9,999 |
| 12 | 10,000 or more |
New · Scale
Within a participant range or an asset range, drag the low and the high end of the fee scale to set the peer group yourself. The Scale slider counts the plans inside it as you go, so you see how many plans the plan is benchmarked against before you rely on the comparison.
Raise the low end to leave out plans with fees far below what comparable services cost. Lower the high end to leave out plans paying for services this plan does not use. The median and the plan’s place in the scaled group update with it.
Fee benchmarking
Scale
Total plan fees, as a percent of plan assets
Bring a plan to a walkthrough and see its fees against its participant range and its asset range.